GT Answers: What is the Difference Between GPS and GLONASS

Navigation devices and navigation apps on smartphones have changed the way we find places. As long as the place you are going is mapped, you can usually find the correct route pretty easily. Even if it isn’t located on the map you are using, it often suffices to find a nearby location and then it isn’t usually difficult to find your way from there.

satellite-soyuz-spaceship-space-station-41006

This navigation where your course is monitored relative to a map of your area is possible largely due to GPS/GLONASS which are 2 different space based global navigation satellite constellations. What is the difference between GPS and GLONASS you ask? Well that’s what we’re getting on to now.

Note: GPS and GLONASS are global navigation satellite systems (GNSS). These work by using signals sent to receivers on earth from satellites in space. By processing data sent from multiple satellites and analyzing how far the receiver is from the satellite, accurate location material can be derived.

GPS

The Global Positioning System (GPS) is a U.S. owned satellite navigation system. It provides users with the following services:

  • Positioning
  • Navigation
  • Timing

It is made up of three components which are:

  • The space segment
  • The control segment
  • The user segment

The U.S. Air Force is responsible for the development, maintenance and operations of the space and control segments.

GPS Satellites orbit the earth in a medium earth orbit at an altitude of 20-200 km with each satellite completing 2 orbits per day.

Space Segment

The space segment refers to the satellites which are in orbit providing the GPS signal.

The satellites are arranged in such a way that a GPS receiver should be able to receive a signal from 4 satellites at any given time. The satellites are ordered into 6 equally spaced orbital planes with 4 available positions.

constellation
Expandable 24-Slot satellite constellation, as defined in the SPS Performance Standard | GPS.GOV
Note: An orbital plane in this case refers to the orientation of the satellites in orbit relative to Earth.

This means that 24 satellites form the foundation of the space segment. In total there are actually 31 operational GPS satellites which ensure that there can be 24 operational satellites most of the time. In the case any of the satellites needs servicing, one of the additional 7 can fill the gap.

Control Segment

The Control Segment of GPS consists of ground facilities spread out across the world. These facilities are used by the U.S. Air Force to make sure that the GPS is continuously available and accurate.

User Segment

The user segment refers to equipment used which communicate with the GPS satellites, providing location and time data for the user.

GLONASS

GLONASS is an acronym for Globalnaya Navigatsionnaya Sputnikovaya Sistema which translates to Global Navigation Satellite System.

Glonass_history
GLONASS | Information And Analysis Center For Positioning, Navigation And Timing

The uses of GLONASS are pretty much the same as those of GPS and it also consists of a space, control and user segment. GLONASS, however, is Russian owned and operated.

GLONASS satellites orbit Earth at an altitude of 19-100 km and also complete about 2 orbits of the earth per day.

Differences

You will notice that I did not mention the number of satellites that are part of the GLONASS fleet. Don’t panic, I simply wanted to save that for this section because that’s one of the things that makes GLONASS different from GPS in addition to their countries of origin.

There are 24 operational GLONASS satellites which operate in 3 orbital planes. There are 8 satellite slots per orbital plane.

In addition to these 2 differences there are 2 others which can be considered the most major ones. Firstly the signal from GPS and GLONASS satellites are different from each other. Their structures are different and while GPS uses code-division channeling, GLONASS uses frequency-division channeling.

Note: The two aforementioned channel access methods describe different frameworks for transmission of signals across a particular transmission medium as well as the sharing of capacity among devices using the method in question.

GPS-meme

The other difference lies in the mathematical models that describe the motion of the two satellite fleets. Two different models are used to describe their motion.

Conclusion

While there are differences between these two satellite constellations, they both provide navigation services both to military personnel and civilians. It has also been shown that the use of both constellations for navigation purposes leads to improved accuracy. Several devices include both GPS and GLONASS chips these days as well.

More information on GPS can be found here while more information on GLONASS can be found here.

ALSO READ: How To Get Offline Maps and Navigation With Maps.me for Android and iPhone

William Elcock

By

See more posts by this author.

Show CommentsHide Comments