Google Messenger vs Other Android SMS Apps

Screenshot 466

In Android 4.4 KitKat, Google removed the default Messages app. SMS and MMS would be integrated with Hangouts. Google was clearly trying to make Hangouts the iMessage of Android but from the get go, there were issues. Unlike iMessage, Hangouts would have different conversation views for SMS and IM and sometimes there was just no clear demarcation between the two.

Now, after more than a year of forcing Hangouts on users, Google has finally come out with a dedicated SMS app of their own called Messenger.

Why would you want to have the Messenger app as your default? How is it better (or worse) than awesome third party SMS apps like GO SMS, Handcent, or Textra that we’ve talked about before? Read on to find out.

Messenger Looks Great

There are no two ways about it. For an SMS app from the company that gave us Android 3.0 Honeycomb (the one you’re not supposed to talk about), Messenger is a stunner.

It follows Material Design closely. Everything from bright colors to animations to ripple effects to the big round floating action button is right there.

2014 11 14 18 06 04
2014 11 14 18 06 11

One stand out feature in Messenger is how each conversation has a different accent color. If the contact you’re chatting with has a profile picture, the app will take the most dominant color from the picture. If there’s no profile picture, the app still assigns different colors to each conversation, albeit randomly.

But Messenger Is Limited

Unfortunately, like other apps Google creates, Messenger feels like a boilerplate. An app that has all the essentials and gets the basics right, but with room for third party apps to build upon.

2014 11 13 19 13 58

In Summation: If what you’re looking for is a stable, uncomplicated way to instant message, go ahead and download Google Messenger. But if you want anything more, you’ll have to look somewhere else.

The Case For Third Party SMS Clients

If you’re a heavy SMS user, you’re going to want more than just a pretty UI and different colored conversation views. Things like quick reply, favorites, do not disturb mode and themes become a big priority.

1. GO SMS Pro Is Still The King Of All Features

Go SMS Pro has been the go-to SMS app for years, even when it wasn’t that good to look at. Now, with version 6.0 it too has Material Design influences and it still carries all the great features that made it what it is today. You have a private conversation view, dual SIM support, themes, emojis and a lot more.

2014 11 14 18 04 11
2014 11 14 18 04 03

While GO SMS Pro has a number of features, over the years it’s put on a bit of weight and has become bloated. Not to mention the ads. And unlocking it all takes an in-app purchase of $7.

Important Update: TechCrunch reported about the GO SMS Pro app for Android carrying a bug that potentially exposes photos, videos, and other files on your phone. Till the developers release a proper update to fix the bug, we recommend moving to the default Messages app with Android RCS messaging or using the Microsoft SMS Organizer app.

2. Handcent Is The GO SMS Pro Without The Baggage

Handcent’s and GO SMS Pro’s feature sets are quite similar. It has the private SMS box, theme support, scheduling features and a lot more.

2014 11 14 18 05 30
2014 11 14 18 05 36

The great thing is that unlike GO, Handcent is still completely free. There are no in-app purchases trying to con you into spending money you don’t really want to.

3. Textra Looks Just As Good As Messenger And Has Better Features

We’ve written about Textra in detail before. The gist is that Textra follows the Material Design language more closely than any other SMS app I’ve seen. It looks gorgeous. And thanks to the theme support, you can customize it as well.

2014 11 14 11 17 53
2014 11 14 11 15 11

My favorite thing about Textra is the quick reply view. Instead of just showing the message and text input box, Textra shows the latest conversation, so you get context without ever jumping into the app itself.

2014 11 14 18 07 27
2014 11 14 18 07 07

It has good features (although not as many as GO and Handcent), looks great, works well and is being actively developed.

4. Hello Is The Google Messenger Replacement

Hello is a minimal SMS app and if for some reason you don’t like Google Messenger but still prefer minimal features, Hello is for you.

2014 11 14 18 05 00
2014 11 14 18 04 54

Hello has a great tabbed interface that allows you to quickly switch between conversations and the dark mode is pretty sweet as well. And of course, the app is completely ad free.

Which One Did You Choose?

Which SMS app did you go with? Let us know in the comments below.

Last updated on 03 February, 2022

The above article may contain affiliate links which help support Guiding Tech. However, it does not affect our editorial integrity. The content remains unbiased and authentic.